"The Request" Blog Series: Part 3

An evaluation matrix for a security contract we reviewed last year allocated the award criteria as follows: 70 percent for quality and 30 percent for price. On paper, this was a request for proposals in which substance carried more weight than cost. However, the quality section described topics on which every serious bidder submits the same proposal, resulting in all bidders ending up within a few points of each other, and price ultimately being the deciding factor.

This is how a well-intentioned request for proposals most often undermines its own purpose. Part 1 of this series discussed what the request for proposals specifies when procuring security services, and Part 2 addressed the choice between hours and results. This third part focuses on the award criteria themselves.

Award Criteria in the 2012 Public Procurement Act

For public contracting authorities, the 2012 Public Procurement Act specifies three award criteria. The guiding principle is the best value for money. The law also specifies the lowest costs based on cost-effectiveness and the lowest price. “Most economically advantageous tender” is the umbrella term for all three. Anyone awarding a contract based on the lowest price in a standard European procedure must justify that choice in the tender documents.

PIANOo, the Dutch government’s center of expertise on public procurement, is strikingly direct about the effect of awarding contracts based on the lowest price. In such cases, bidders almost always offer the minimum required quality, resulting in a product that barely meets the standards. In this model, the contractor is also pressured to exclude as many costs as possible in order to drive down the price. This assessment comes from an organization that has no commercial interest whatsoever in how you conduct your procurement process.

When it comes to security, the framework is different from what many buyers assume. Security services fall under the category known as “social and other specific services,” abbreviated as SAS. The European Public Procurement Directive treats this category separately because these services are typically local in nature and are rarely procured across borders. In addition to security, this category includes healthcare, education, legal services, and hotel and restaurant services, among others.

A European threshold of 750,000 euros applies to SAS services. If the value of your contract exceeds this amount, you must follow a simplified procedure that you are largely free to design yourself. In that case, you are not bound by the fixed European deadlines and procedural steps, as long as you announce the contract in advance and publish the award decision. The principles of equal treatment and transparency remain fully applicable, so your award criteria and their weighting must be known in advance and objectively verifiable. Below the threshold, the Proportionality Guide provides guidance.

A complete explanation can be found in our knowledge article, “Rules, Thresholds, and Procedures at a Glance.” This flexibility is a reason to carefully design the quality criteria, because it gives you more freedom to reward what matters most to your location. Anyone awarding a contract based on the lowest price or lowest cost in a standard European procedure must justify that choice in the procurement documents.

The Difference Between Requirements and Award Criteria

The distinction that causes the most harm in practice is that between a requirement and an award criterion.

A requirement is a deal-breaker: bidders must meet it fully and unconditionally to be eligible. An award criterion rewards those who offer more than the minimum, thereby distinguishing between bidders.

We regularly see clients include their quality expectations in their requirements—ranging from certifications and qualified personnel to industry experience and availability outside of business hours. This leaves little room for factors that truly set a bid apart during the award process, after which price becomes the deciding factor.

The rule of thumb is simple. Include in the requirements what you absolutely need and what can be objectively verified. Reserve the award criteria for the areas where bidders truly differ from one another and for which you are willing to pay a premium.

Award Criteria That Predict the Quality of a Security Contract

Below are the factors that, based on our experience in fulfilling our own contracts, we have found to predict the outcome of a collaboration.

Permanent staffing at your location. Of all the metrics, employee turnover is the strongest predictor of what you’ll experience in two years. As a contract award criterion, this topic must relate to your specific contract and not to the company as a whole; historical company figures are part of the selection process. Therefore, ask how the bidder ensures a permanent workforce at your location, what percentage of permanent employees they commit to, and what KPIs and penalties they intend to link to that commitment. Staff turnover in the service area over the past three years can serve as evidence of that commitment. Always ask for the definition as well, because figures without a definition are not comparable. We calculate turnover as the number of employees who leave the company in a year, divided by the average number of employees on staff. According to that definition, our turnover rate in 2025 was 14 percent.

The onboarding and handover process. Ask how a new employee is onboarded at your specific location and who determines whether someone is ready to work independently. An anonymized work instruction reveals, even at first glance, whether an organization has taken this process seriously.

The replacement structure. Ask what happens in the event of illness, leave, or absences, and what percentage of replacements are filled by someone who is already familiar with your location. This answer distinguishes organizations that work with teams from those that simply slot a name into the schedule for each shift.

The team you’ll actually be working with. Ask for the name and title of the contract manager or regional team leader, and find out how many other accounts that person manages. Also ask what happens if that person leaves.

The implementation plan. Ask how the first 90 days will proceed, who will be involved during that time, and when the provider expects the service to be delivered. The fourth part of this series is entirely devoted to this topic.

A conversation with the people who will actually be running the account. A conversation, interview, or presentation as part of the evaluation is permitted but rarely used. Invite the people who will be managing the account, so you’re not just speaking with the team that wrote the proposal. Within twenty minutes, you’ll know if someone is familiar with your type of venue.

For reception positions, that last criterion is the most important. Introduce the prospective receptionist to a colleague who greets visitors on a daily basis. Also ask who the regular substitute is and how often they work at your reception desk.

Award Criteria That Are Less Meaningful Than Expected

We also identify which criteria yield little benefit, including those on which we ourselves score well.

Certifications demonstrate that processes are in place and are subject to external audits. They provide a necessary foundation, although they say little about continuity at your location, since virtually every reputable provider has them.

Comprehensive action plans yield fewer results than their scope might suggest. They are often written by people who do not carry out the work afterward, which means that the quality of the document says more about a bidder’s tender department than anything else.

References and company size are actually selection criteria in a bid process: they say something about the bidder, not about the bid itself. Even in that role, they are less useful than is often thought.

CO2 Performance Ladder and Social Return in the Request for Proposals

Social return is a more promising topic for security than for many other procurement categories, because the work is labor-intensive. Since 2011, the national government has applied social return to contracts for works and services exceeding 250,000 euros. This is usually done as a contract condition: the contractor commits to spending a portion of the contract value during execution on employment or training for people who are distanced from the labor market. It can also be included as an award criterion, for example, by evaluating the contractor’s implementation plan.

The target group for the job agreement has been broadened to a limited extent as of 2026. This group is part of the target group for social return, which is defined more broadly in most requests for proposals.

Determine for each contract whether social return is proportionate, as PIANOo also strongly recommends. A requirement that does not align with the nature of the work results in a paper exercise that benefits no one. In the security sector, there are real opportunities when you give providers flexibility in how they fulfill their social return obligations, for example through training programs for career changers. For a multi-year contract for facility security in the Drechtsteden region, we fulfilled the social return requirement through the SERIS Academy. Four career changers from the target group completed the MBO 2 Security Guard training program with us and completed their practical training hours at the client’s facility. All four were offered employment contracts after receiving their diplomas.

Weighting and Scoring Method: Review Your Evaluation Matrix in Advance

The weights you assign to the criteria, together with the scoring method, determine the final ranking. Two calls for proposals with identical criteria can result in different winners based solely on the scoring method.

We recommend testing the scoring method before you publish it. Run the numbers for a few fictitious bids and see if the results match your expectations. If a bidder with the lowest quality score still wins based on price, then quality actually carries less weight than the matrix suggests.

PIANOo recommends that criteria be formulated as a team. For security purposes, we would suggest including someone who is on site every day, such as the facility manager or the night shift team leader, because they know when issues tend to arise.

Please keep in mind that awarding a contract based on the best value for money requires more work than awarding it based on the lowest price—both for you and for the bidders. In the security sector, where there are significant differences in quality among providers, that investment pays off.

Where Quality-Based Contracting Goes Wrong in Practice

In our experience, things rarely go wrong because clients don’t care enough about quality. The problem is often that translating that intention into measurable criteria doesn’t work, causing the matrix to function differently than intended. Anyone who runs through hypothetical bids in advance and brings the people from the site to the table can prevent most of those problems.

The fourth and final part of this series focuses on a period that is rarely described in any request for proposals: the first ninety days after the contract is awarded. Would you like to know how we answer the questions in this article? We’d be happy to explain our turnover rate and share an anonymized example of a work instruction.

FAQ – Award Criteria for Security Contracts

The best value for money, the lowest costs based on cost-effectiveness, and the lowest price. “Most economically advantageous bid” is the umbrella term for these criteria.

Yes, but it’s rarely a good idea. Security is a social and other specific service (SAS). For contracts above 750,000 euros, a somewhat relaxed European regulatory framework applies, under which you are largely free to choose the procedure and award criteria yourself. For companies in special sectors, such as port authorities, that threshold is 1 million euros. The principles of equal treatment and transparency always apply. According to PIANOo, awarding contracts based on the lowest price leads in practice to a level of quality that is barely adequate.

A requirement is a deal-breaker: bidders must fully meet it to be eligible. An award criterion distinguishes between bidders and rewards those who offer more than the minimum. Quality objectives that end up in the requirements can no longer serve to distinguish between bidders.

Ensuring a stable on-site staff, the onboarding and handover process, the replacement structure in case of illness or leave, the specific team managing the account, and the implementation plan for the first few months. A meeting with the key personnel can be included as part of the assessment. If so, designate those individuals as key personnel in their contracts.

Yes, this is a common practice, whereby a higher step on the ladder results in a notional discount on the registration fee. Please specify in your documents which version of the ladder you are requesting.

Yes, because security is labor-intensive. Social return is usually included as a contract condition and sometimes as an award criterion. For each contract, it must be determined whether the effort involved is proportionate.

Share this article

Related articles

  • Security Requirements Specification

    Security Requirements Specification: Procuring Hours or Procuring Results

    Blog Series: The Request for Proposals—Part 2 On the buyer’s desk are three proposals based on the same … read more

    9-minute readPublished on: October 19, 2026
  • srcset="data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg%20xmlns%3D%27http%3A%2F%2Fwww.w3.org%2F2000%2Fsvg%27%20width%3D%27950%27%20height%3D%27260%27%20viewBox%3D%270%200%20950%20260%27%3E%3Crect%20width%3D%27950%27%20height%3D%27260%27%20fill-opacity%3D%220%22%2F%3E%3C%2Fsvg%3E"

    Security Procurement: Rules, Thresholds, and Procedures at a Glance

    Anyone preparing a security procurement bid for a public organization must first determine whether that organization is subject to procurement requirements and ... read more

    9.7-minute readPublished on: October 13, 2026
  • security procurement

    Procuring Security Services: Your Request Determines What You Get

    Blog Series: The Request—Part 1 A request we received last year contained twenty lines about ... read more

    11.2-minute readPublished on: October 12, 2026